There is a defining moment in "May Baby is Missing" in which Jenna Davis sees a baby and intuitively recognizes that it is her little Madeleine who was stolen from her. She then collects her evidence and defiantly tells the incompetent police, "I want my baby!!!"

The film unfolded a diabolical scheme in human trafficking when Nicole Parker passes herself off as a prenatal care nurse, pays a visit to Jenna's house, drugs the very pregnant Jenna, induces labor, and steals her baby.

Much of the narrative involves Jenna and the father of the child, Tom Robbins, fending off the police, who wish to charge Jenna with homicide! The caliber of investigative work turned in by the police reaches a new low in this film. But the quick-thinking Tom notices in a video recording that the license plate of Nicole Parker was captured on camera. That is the first step that leads the two sleuths to discover the truth about Jenna's kidnapped baby.

There was a loose plot strand in the film that never disclosed how Nicole Parker, using the alias Lynne Mallory, was able to show up at Jenna's home after she called the prenatal care center recommended to her by Dr. Morris. It appeared as though the head of the center was a confederate of Nicole and, in one brief scene, she was seen caring for the kidnapped baby until it could be sold by nefarious creature Dolan Severs. Maggie, the head of the prenatal care center, should have been arrested along with Dolan Severs and Nicole Parker.

After Jenna's ordeal, there was a touching reunion of mother and daughter, as Jenna decides to "get her priorities straight" by taking time away from her high-pressure job as VP of Klein-Walters Advertising. Tom also will quit his job to help raise the new baby. When it comes to finances, the couple's brilliant solution is as follows: "We'll figure it out!"