I can see why the Film Foundation spent some money bringing back Two Girls on the Street (or as they might say in Hungary, Ket lany az uccan), it's rather astounding. Directed by Endre Toth (or as they might say in Hollywood, Andre De Toth) in the cinematic miracle year of 1939, it tells the tale of two women, one jilted by her two-timing lover and forced to play violin in an all-girl gin joint band and the other a newly minted orphan who is broke and broken by a stream of grabby heels, as they move up from their crummy street to the Budapest equivalent of Park Avenue.
What is so extraordinary is the frankness De Toth brings to the story. After getting impregnated by her caddish boyfriend, Giyongyi (Maria Fekete) does not waste a minute and pays an immediate visit to an abortion clinic to rid herself of his baby, which we experience in full right there with her. Yikes. Her youthful ward, Vica's (Bella Bordy), own encounters with her creeps are equally frank. Comparisons with the hard edged depression themed films that were coming out of Warner Brothers in the early '30s are hard to miss, although this is no gold digger film and honestly has more of an MGM vibe, although nothing like this would ever come out of that studio, particularly that far into the Code.
There are some problems with the story to my way of thinking, particularly Vica's attraction to one of her early man problems, but they are easy to overlook when contemplating the whole. All in all well worth tracking down.
Two Girls on the Street
1939 [HUNGARIAN]
Comedy / Drama
Plot summary
Two girls run away from a small village. Gyöngyi comes from an aristocratic family and her father throws her out of the house when he discovers she has gotten pregnant out of wedlock. She finds herself wandering the streets of Budapest and earns money playing the violin in a restaurant. Vica is an orphaned peasant; she is afraid of her stepfather and moves to the city where she gets a job on a construction site. Gyöngyi and Vica meet on the streets of Budapest, move in together and turn their lives around.
Uploaded by: FREEMAN
May 26, 2023 at 05:04 PM
Director
Top cast
Tech specs
720p.BLU 1080p.BLUMovie Reviews
Give that man a job, Hollywood...
Almost great
In a lot of ways, Two Girls on the Street is shockingly, and refreshingly, modern. The editing and cinematography is elaborate, the plot is about underprivileged women, and it's unafraid to confront difficult subject matter head-on. And yet, as the film enters the third act, it eventually falls victim to convention and makes several concessions to theoretically be more friendly to a mainstream audience-at the cost of its artistic integrity.
Both protagonists are very different people: Gyongyi is a disgraced woman forced out of her family who eventually winds up as a performer in an all-woman band. Vica has to do backbreaking labor at a construction site to support herself, all the while being sexually harassed and assaulted by the male workers. After a particularly bad night of abuse, Vica meets and is subsequently taken in by Gyongyi. The two become friends and navigate through love and life in 1930s Hungary.
The general premise is very interesting and has a lot of room for social commentary. There's hints towards the protagonists' relationship being more than platonic, which is subtext that opens up many storytelling possibilities. Aided by both women's vulnerable and convincing performances, their dynamic is interesting to watch, and each character has a surprising amount of depth. In general, it's pretty remarkable to see an old film be so unafraid to showcase female independence and critique male chauvinism.
On a technical level, Two Girls on the Street is also impressive. There are lots of dissolves, quick cuts, pans, and even some inventive music choices at a time when most movies would just settle for the bare minimum. The costume and production design is also really interesting, although the hairstyles of the leads are so similar that it can sometimes be hard to tell them apart. Regardless, I didn't have high expectations for a probably low-budget 1930s film, and they were still exceeded.
However, all of these positives come with a major caveat: the ending. The man who assaulted Vica happens to live in the apartment she and Gyongyi just moved in to, and she falls head-over-heels for him. Gyongyi tries to separate the two, although not because of how dangerous he is. At first, I thought this was a clever and ironic twist that the two women were fighting over a man when they had bonded over their bad experiences with them, also serving as a metaphor for the all-encompassing inevitability of a patriarchy's effect. Maybe Vica's newfound obsession is a symptom of her trauma that she then has to reconnect with Gyongyi to overcome.
But that's not what ends up happening. Gyongyi breaking them up causes Vica to attempt suicide. Gyongyi expresses regret over her actions, and, after her recovery, Vica officially gets together with her abuser.
This ending is all wrong. It's shown very early on how horrible Vica's treated, only for the film to turn around by the end and suddenly expect us to root for their love. Part of me hopes that it's an intentionally sad ending about the way society doesn't treat sexual assault with the degree of seriousness that it deserves, but the swelling musical score when they're in each other's arms says otherwise. It's frankly dumbfounding that such a smart and feminist movie suddenly has such an unfitting and frustrating ending that reaffirms male superiority.
But if you can get over the ending, Two Girls on the Street is a great, progressive exploration of women in our society. The storyline it explores is interesting, the technical quality is astonishing, and the themes it touches on still resonate today. It's just such a pity that it couldn't stick the landing.
Final Score: 73/100.